Wednesday, May 29, 2013
A bullish magazine cover story right at the top of a big run-up in stock prices makes one reasonably wonder whether or not the Japanese equity party is over. My answer? Not by a long shot.
From the point of view of contrarian theory the cover of The Economist is not as significant a long-term contrarian indicator as it may appear to be at first glance. Tale a look at the top chart which shows the Nikkei stock average on a monthly basis going back to its all time high (red line) in December 1989. As you can see, despite rhe recent run-up, this average is still trading 60% lower than it was at its 1989 high. As I explained in my book it is very unlikely that a bullish investment crowd will grow to bubble-popping size until the market is at all time highs. So I conclude that the bullish cover actually marks the birth of a bullish investment crowd in the Japanese stock market, not the end of the growth of such a crowd.
I have another reason for doubting that this cover marks any sort of important top in the Nikkei or low in the yen. The Bank of Japan has embarked on a massive quantitative easing program which is scheduled to run for two years. I for one think the BOJ now means business and I expect its purchases of Japanese bonds to continue. But given the BOJ's track record many investors doubt that it will continue its QE program. So I think there is a lot of room on the upside in the Nikkei and on the downside in the yen which will be occupied by the charts as skeptical investors start believing in the BOJ's announced intentions.
It is worth mentioning that QE in Japan is bullish for the US stock market too as it is for the rest of the world's markets. The same can be said for the Fed's QE program. So short term fluctuations aside world stock markets are almost certainly headed higher from current levels.
Thursday, May 16, 2013
According to Paul Montgomery's magazine cover theory this bullish cover is a definite negative for the stock market going forward. However, such covers on average preceded bull market tops by 4 months or so. This means that prices are likely to move still higher before anything resembling a bear market begins.
I would add that this cover is less representative of the investing public's mood than a similar cover on a general circulation magazine. I don't think there is anything like a bullish investment crowd operating in the US stock market right now. If fact I would characterize investors' attitudes towards the stock market as skeptical.The low levels of trading volume and volatility also testify in support of my conclusion.
However the rally of nearly 10% during the past month has caught investor's attention. Measured by the five day moving average of the CBOE equity put-call ratio there is more bullishness in the market than has been seen in more than a year.
The coupling of the fast, one month rally, a bullish magazine cover, and a relatively low put-call ratio suggests that a temporary interruption of this bull market is imminent. But I don't think it will be a very big interruption. The most likely development would be a drop to the vicinity of the S&P's 50 day moving average (green wavy line) and possibly to the level of the 2007 top at 1576.
The bull market which followed the bursting of the dot.com bubble lasted five full years. By that clock the current bull market could easily last until March of 2014 although I think a top sooner than that, perhaps in the fall of 2013, is more likely.